San Bernardino bishop urges prayers for unity, healing after shootings

By Mike Nelson

Catholic News Service

OXNARD, Calif. (CNS) — Arriving in the late morning Dec. 2 at the San Bernardino diocesan pastoral center for his job in the diocese’s Office of Worship, Chris Estrella knew something was very wrong.

"I could see a police blockade of Waterman Avenue, which is where the Inland Regional Center is located," said Estrella, music and liturgy assistant.

"That’s less than two miles from the pastoral center. Then I saw a lot of law enforcement in the area — and I needed to use my key to get in the building, which is unusual."

Once at his desk, Estrella turned on his computer and saw the reason for the blockade and increased security: The Inland Regional Center had become a murder scene, with 14 people killed and 17 more wounded.

"At that time, realistically, I felt safe," Estrella, 27, told Catholic News Service Dec. 3. "But I worried about my family — my parents, my siblings including my little brother who attends Our Lady of the Assumption School not that far away. Fortunately they were all safe."

But the pastoral center — and Catholic schools in the city — remained on lockdown for several hours until about 2 p.m. "when they began shuffling us out and told us, ‘Go home, be with your families,’" said Estrella. The office remained closed Dec. 3, and was already slated to be closed Dec. 4 for first Friday observances.

The Office of Worship canceled a Dec. 3 formation class for the Rite of Christian Initiation of Adults program at the pastoral center. In a statement, the office expressed its sorrow at the killings and its solidarity in prayer with families and victims of the tragedy, saying, "Let us pray for peace and mutual tolerance, moving forward."

While no additional prayer services had been scheduled as of Dec. 3, Estrella noted that the diocesan Department of Life, Dignity and Justice had previously scheduled an evening vigil Dec. 5 for victims of violence at Sacred Heart Church in Rancho Cucamonga, in the western portion of the diocese that includes San Bernardino and Riverside counties.

"I expect we will be remembering the victims of the (Inland Regional Center) at that event," said Estrella, who added that more plans for prayer liturgies and Catholic community outreach will be discussed at a Dec. 7 meeting with diocesan staff and led by San Bernardino Bishop R. Gerald Barnes.

"Like Bishop Barnes said (in a Dec. 2 statement), this is a time for prayer, a time to pray for peace," said Estrella. "I know there are many people all over who are praying for us here in such a terrible time, and I want to extend my thanks to all of them. We don’t need any more violence."

Bishop Barnes attended a candlelight vigil Dec. 3 at San Manuel Stadium in San Bernardino to remember those who died in the shooting. During the service, the names of the 14 people who were killed were read aloud.

The bishop, in a tweet sent Dec. 3, said it was a "blessing to come together with leaders of our community tonight" to pray for peace and healing.

In a statement the previous day, Bishop Barnes urged people to pray for unity and healing after the mass shooting.

"For those who lost their lives, we pray for their eternal rest and God’s strength to their loved ones left behind; for those who are wounded, we pray for their health and healing," he said.

The bishop called on people to pray for "all of the victims of this horrific incident and their families" and also asked for prayers for law enforcement officers who at the time were still "pursuing the suspects in this case."

"Our community of San Bernardino has faced great challenges through the years. Let us come together now in unity to bring light to the darkness of this day," Bishop Barnes said.

The shooting took place at the Inland Regional Center, a state-run facility for individuals with developmental disabilities where county health officials were having an employee holiday party.

Two armed suspects — later identified as Syed Farook, 28, and Tashfeen Malik, 27 — were killed by police four hours later in a shootout about two miles from the social services center.

Farook, a county environmental inspector, had attended the holiday party and left, returning with Malik, wearing "assault-style clothing" with ammunition attached, according to news reports.

Police and federal agents have not yet offered a motive for the couple’s shootings at the center, which provides housing and work programs and therapy and social services to more than 30,000 people with developmental disabilities. But federal law enforcement officials told The New York Times Dec. 4 that Farook’s wife, Malik, had pledged allegiance to the Islamic State in a Facebook posting. The FBI announced Dec. 4 that it is officially investigating the shooting as an act of terrorism.

Los Angeles Archbishop Jose H. Gomez said in a Dec. 3 statement that it is "hard to understand this kind of violence and the hatred that motivates it.

"We ask how people can do such things, what is in their hearts? In these times, we need to trust in the providence of God and rely on his mercy."

"Our Christian faith tells us that we must overcome evil with good and respond to hatred with love. So this is our challenge in the days ahead," he added.

The archbishop said the Los Angeles Archdiocese mourns with the families and loved ones of victims and prays for healing for the wounded.

"We ask that God give his wisdom and prudence to the public authorities and law enforcement officials who are seeking to make sense of this horrible crime. And we pray for the conversion of hearts that are hardened by hatred," he said.

At least one of the shooting victims was Catholic — Bennetta Betbadal, who was born in Iran in 1969. According to a fundraising page set up for her children, she fled to the United States when she was 18 to escape Islamic extremism and the persecution of Christians following the Iranian Revolution. She and her husband, both Catholic, had three children and lived in Rialto.

The day of the shooting, Betbadal, a health inspector, was at the Inland Regional Center to give a presentation.

"She loved her job, her community, and her country," the fundraising page says. "Her greatest love, however, was for her husband, her children, and her large extended family."

– – –

Contributing to this story was Carol Zimmermann in Washington.

Copyright © 2024 Catholic News Service, Inc. All rights reserved. Linking is encouraged, but republishing or redistributing, including by framing or similar means, without the publisher's prior written permission is prohibited.

No, Thanks